How to Choose Between Reupholstering and Slipcovering Your Furniture

When a well-used sofa or favorite chair starts to show signs of wear, you may find yourself wondering whether to reupholster furniture or go with a slipcover. Both options can transform the look of your upholstered furniture, but the best solution depends on your goals, budget, and the current condition of the piece.

If you’re deciding between a custom slipcover or full restoration, this guide explores the key differences and when each option makes the most sense.

What’s the Difference?

Slipcovers are fabric covers that fit over existing furniture upholstery. A custom slipcover is tailored to the specific dimensions of your piece, offering a more precise fit than mass-produced options. Slipcovers can be removed and washed, making them a practical choice for families or high-traffic areas.

Reupholstering involves stripping the furniture down to its frame, repairing or replacing internal materials like foam and springs, and applying new upholstery fabric. This is a full restoration and offers long-term results.

When a Slipcover Might Be the Right Choice

1. You want a fast and affordable update
Furniture slipcovers are generally more budget-friendly and can quickly change the look of a room.

2. You need protection for high-use furniture
Custom slipcovers are ideal for busy households with kids or pets. They can be easily removed, washed, or replaced without damaging the original fabric.

3. You like to switch up your décor
If your tastes or seasons change often, having multiple custom slipcovers allows for flexible styling without permanent commitment.

4. The structure and cushioning are still in good shape
If your sofa or chair is still supportive and comfortable, a slipcover may be all you need to make it feel like new.

When Reupholstery Is the Better Investment

1. The furniture has a high-quality or sentimental frame
Older pieces and heirloom furniture often have solid hardwood frames that are worth preserving.

2. The cushions or internal support are worn out
Reupholstering allows you to replace foam, springs, and padding—restoring comfort, not just looks.

3. You want a clean, tailored, and permanent result
Unlike slipcovers, which may shift or wrinkle, upholstery work provides a sleek, fitted finish using your chosen upholstery fabric.

4. You’re not ready to buy new furniture
Reupholstering offers the comfort and style of new furniture without the hassle of shopping or assembly—and often at a lower total cost.

Slipcover vs Reupholstery: Key Questions to Ask

• Is the frame of the furniture still strong and in good condition?

• Are you looking for a temporary or long-term update?

• Do you want to improve comfort and support as well as appearance?

• Is a polished, custom look important for your living space?

If you’re primarily focused on convenience and flexibility, custom slipcovers are a great choice. But if you’re restoring a well-loved piece or aiming for a like-new finish, reupholstery offers superior results.

Upholstery Fabric and Style Considerations

Both options allow you to personalize your piece with fabric. With slipcovers, you might choose a machine-washable cotton or performance blend. For reupholstery, a wider range of upholstery fabrics is available, from luxurious velvets to durable microfiber. Whether you’re dressing up a formal armchair or refreshing a casual family room sofa, the right fabric can elevate any room.

If you’re considering outdoor slipcovers or want extra durability, there are weather-resistant options available as well. Talk to an expert about selecting fabric that balances comfort, function, and style.

Get Expert Help from Gomez Upholstery

At Gomez Upholstery, we help you make the right decision for your space and lifestyle. Whether you’re looking to refresh a couch with a custom slipcover or completely transform a piece through reupholstery, we deliver high-quality results with personalized service.

We offer:

• Free consultations and honest recommendations based on your furniture’s condition

• A large library of upholstery fabric choices to fit your needs

• Custom slipcovers tailored to your furniture

• Full-service reupholstery that restores comfort and beauty

Ready to Update Your Sofa or Chair?

Let us help you decide between custom slipcovers and reupholstery. Call 314-832-8331 or fill out our Contact Form to schedule your free consultation.

Gomez Upholstery – Transforming Furniture Across St. Louis
Proudly serving Maryland Heights, St. Louis, and surrounding areas with craftsmanship that lasts. Whether you want to revive old furniture or avoid buying new furniture, we make it easy to love your furniture again.